Bombarded! Over two-thirds of consumers are still being sent irrelevant messages by retailers

With the high street reporting negative sales for the first time in more than two years, it’s clear that retailers are continuing to face a challenging and competitive environment. Yet, at a time when positive and personalised experiences are more critical than ever, new findings reveal many retailers are not meeting the mark, with over two-thirds (69%) of consumers reporting that they receive irrelevant messages from brands and 41% saying they do not feel valued when it comes to the service offered.

49% of shoppers' inboxes bombarded

The study, undertaken by CM.com, a global leader in cloud software for conversational commerce, highlights that consumers are frustrated with the personalisation approach taken by retailers, with almost half (49%) citing that this is due to their inbox being bombarded, harming their perception of the brand’s overall service. Almost a third (31%) are annoyed by brands communicating with them on channels they don’t want to use and conversely, nearly a quarter (22%) feel frustrated by the inability to contact brands through their preferred channels. Over one in three (36%) UK shoppers become ‘extremely frustrated’ when companies use incorrect information in customer communication.

When it comes to data, nearly a third (30%) of respondents report privacy concerns in this area when it comes to personalisation efforts on the part of UK retailers, while 63% don’t think purchase history is acceptable data for brands to draw on when providing a personalised customer experience. In fact, just 31% of shoppers are comfortable with companies accessing their shopping behaviour.

45% of consumers believe brands don’t have a good understanding of their needs or expectations

For brands, understanding where work is needed to get consumers onside with a truly personalised customer experience is vital to enabling better relationships long-term. Over half (57%) of respondents expect personalisation most when they’ve purchased a product multiple times before, whereas for 48% it is when they’ve made the first product purchase. Currently, 42% of UK shoppers feel that companies do not meet their expectations when it comes to personalisation and over a third (39%) state that companies do not communicate with them in a way that makes them feel understood. A similar proportion (45%) think that brands don’t have a good understanding of their needs or expectations.

James Matthews, UK & Ireland Country Manager at CM.com, comments: “Personalisation as a business practice currently is not driving the value that brands would neither hope nor expect. Consumers want an experience tailored to them, which brands are failing to get right as it stands. Shoppers are clearly unconvinced that the quid pro quo of data sharing for an enhanced experience is a worthwhile trade, and they are voicing those frustrations loud and clear. With poor personalisation likely impacting the bottom line at a time when business revenues are already stretched, this should serve as a significant warning and a sign that change needs to happen. This doesn’t mean to say that personalisation is a failure, but more that the current approaches being taken by some brands aren’t aligned with consumer expectations, especially in the era of significant advances in artificial intelligence which, amongst other things, enables the ability to offer tailored services to all.

“While it may seem like an uphill battle, there are opportunities for brands to demonstrate the positive impact that good personalisation can have on the overall service. Chatbots and customer communications services are clear areas where personalisation can improve the efficiency of the experience for the end user, which in turn can help to drive loyalty. Likewise, improved AI-powered chatbots can provide superior customer guidance supporting human agents with personalised service. With the right tools in place, retail brands can deliver a truly personalised experience that isn’t invasive and provides shoppers with the right information, driving better relationships and repeat purchases.”

---

Methodology

CM.com conducted this research in cooperation with the independent research agency CANDID. The online survey was conducted in May 2023, where 9964 respondents across the globe answered questions about personalisation and service interactions with businesses. From those 9964 respondents, 1000 UK respondents were surveyed. All respondents were aged 18 years or older.